Closest dupe
Dupe Score 91
Maybelline
Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil, Deep Brown, 1…
$4.00·Save 80%·Excellent dupe
✦ BrowPremium pick
Benefit
.002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown
$19.95
List price · Amazon USD
- Dupes mapped
- 32
- Top save
- 84%
- Best score
- Dupe Score 91
Closest dupe
Maybelline
Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil, Deep Brown, 1…
$4.00
DupeScore 91 — save 80% vs Benefit. Same brow category; compare formula and finish before you swap.
Ranked alternatives
All dupes for Benefit .002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown
Every alternative is scored with our DupeScore — category overlap, savings, and match confidence. Order is computed, not sponsored.
Dupe Score 89
NYX
PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Precision Eyebrow Pencil, Ash Brown
$3.18·Save 84%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 88
NYX
PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Zero to Brow, Longwear Eyebrow…
$3.28·Save 84%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 88
wet n wild
Ultimate Brow Micro Eyebrow Retractable Pencil, Soft…
$3.18·Save 84%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 88
NYX
PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP The Brow Glue, Extreme Hold…
$3.28·Save 84%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 87
Maybelline
Express Brow Ultra Slim Eyebrow Makeup, Brow Pencil…
$3.79·Save 81%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 86
e.l.f. Cosmetics
Micro-Fine Brow Pencil, Black
$3.28·Save 84%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 86
Almay
Brow Styler Eyebrow Gel, Clear, 1 Count
$3.28·Save 84%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 86
L'Oreal
Paris Makeup Brow Stylist Definer Waterproof Eyebrow…
$3.18·Save 84%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 85
e.l.f. Cosmetics
Wow Brow Gel, Volumizing, Buildable, Wax-Gel Hybrid,…
$3.29·Save 84%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 85
L.A
. COLORS Browie Wowie Brow Tinted Gel, Dark Brown CBG413
$3.28·Save 84%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 84
L’Oréal
Paris Brow Stylist Shape and Fill Mechanical Eye Brow…
$3.18·Save 84%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 84
e.l.f. Cosmetics
Instant Lift Brow Pencil, Dual-Sided, Blonde
$3.18·Save 84%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 84
Revlon
ColorStay Brow Fantasy Pencil and Gel, 003 Medium Brown
$5.76·Save 71%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 82
Ardell Brow Sculpting Gel
Clear, Long-Lasting, Easy Application Smudge-Proof…
$3.96·Save 80%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 82
Maybelline
TattooStudio Brow Pomade Long Lasting, Buildable,…
$6.41·Save 68%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 82
NYX
PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Micro Brow Pencil, Precise Eyebrow…
$7.47·Save 63%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 81
Maybelline
Superfluff Volumizing Brow Mousse, All Day Tinted Brow…
$4.88·Save 76%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 81
Maybelline
TattooStudio Waterproof Eyebrow Gel Makeup, Deep…
$7.99·Save 60%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 81
Joah
Brow Down To Me Dual Brow Pencil and Gel, Ash Brown
$7.97·Save 60%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 80
Arches
and Halos Luxury Brow Building Pomade - Vegan Eyebrow…
$5.98·Save 70%·Strong dupe
Dupe Score 79
Maybelline
Super Lock Brow Glue Eyebrow Gel, Lightweight and…
$5.96·Save 70%·Solid match
Dupe Score 79
Revlon
PhotoReady Lifting Brow Gel, 803 Warm Medium Brown,…
$8.99·Save 55%·Solid match
Dupe Score 78
Bundle of
Microblading Supplies 6 Piece Inkless Double Sided…
$7.19·Save 64%·Solid match
Dupe Score 78
Clairol
Root Touch Up Permanent Hair Dye, 5 Medium Brown, Pack…
$7.46·Save 63%·Solid match
Dupe Score 77
Wunderbrow
Frame and Set Brow Gel, Clear Eyebrow Gel for…
$6.75·Save 66%·Solid match
Dupe Score 76
Maybelline
Brow Inserts Eyebrow Pen, Micro Needle Shaped 2-In-1…
$8.54·Save 57%·Solid match
Dupe Score 76
Maybelline
Tattoo Studio Brow Styling Gel, Waterproof Eyebrow…
$8.95·Save 55%·Solid match
Dupe Score 75
Revlon
ColorStay Brow Fiber Filler Brow Gel, 303 Medium…
$8.95·Save 55%·Solid match
Dupe Score 75
Covergirl
Clean Fresh Brow, 500 Medium Brown, Eyebrow Gel,…
$8.98·Save 55%·Solid match
Dupe Score 71
Kara Beauty Brow Lift
Clear Eyebrow Gel for Laminated Look, Extreme Hold…
$4.97·Save 75%·Solid match
How we rank dupes
- 1. Category matchSame product type — brow vs brow, not random cross-sells.
- 2. DupeScoreSimilarity, savings %, and editorial confidence combined into one 0–100 score.
- 3. Side-by-side proofEach pick links to a full compare page with prices, specs, and an honest verdict.