Dupe Score 91
Brow
Benefit vs Maybelline
.002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown · Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil, Deep Brown, 1…
95% matchSave 80%
Confirmed dupe
Clairoldupe forBenefit
Root Touch Up Permanent Hair Dye, 5 Medium Brown, Pack…·replaces .002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown
Save ~62%: Clairol Root Touch Up Permanent Hair Dye, 5 Medium Brown, Pack… is our top budget pick vs Benefit .002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown (89% category/use-case overlap).
What you're replacing
Benefit .002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown
$19.95
Buy this instead
Clairol Root Touch Up Permanent Hair Dye, 5 Medium Brown, Pack…
$7.46
Save $12 (63% less)
Why this dupe works
If you want the Benefit vibe without the splurge, start with Clairol Root Touch Up Permanent Hair Dye, 5 Medium Brown, Pack…. Shoppers report similar results for everyday brow wear; swap only if you need the exact luxury shade, finish, or brand experience.
Before you switch
Dupes match category and use case — not always an identical shade or formula. Read the full comparison for shade and formula trade-offs.
Price drop alert
Notify me if this dupe gets cheaper
We watch Clairol Root Touch Up Permanent Hair Dye, 5 Medium Brown, Pack… (currently $7.46) and email you when the price drops.
Free weekly emails
New Benefit dupes by email
We email when we add fresh matchups for this brand — no spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Keep exploring
Similar dupes you might like
Dupe Score 89
Brow
Benefit vs NYX
.002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown · PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Precision Eyebrow Pencil, Ash Brown
92% matchSave 84%
Dupe Score 87
Brow
Benefit vs Maybelline
.002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown · Express Brow Ultra Slim Eyebrow Makeup, Brow Pencil…
91% matchSave 81%
Dupe Score 88
Brow
Benefit vs NYX
.002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown · PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Zero to Brow, Longwear Eyebrow…
91% matchSave 84%
Dupe Score 88
Brow
Benefit vs wet n wild
.002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown · Ultimate Brow Micro Eyebrow Retractable Pencil, Soft…
91% matchSave 84%
Dupe Score 88
Brow
Benefit vs NYX
.002 Oz Eyebrow Pencil 4 Warm Deep Brown · PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP The Brow Glue, Extreme Hold…
91% matchSave 84%