✦ Setting SprayPremium pick

’Til Dawn Big and Bitty Mattifying Waterproof Setting…

$28.99

List price · Amazon USD

Dupes mapped: 32
Top save: 90%
Best score: Dupe Score 86

Closest dupe

L.A

. COLORS Matte Setting Spray (carded), Clear CBSS704…

$2.99

DupeScore 86 — save 90% vs On. Same setting spray category; compare formula and finish before you swap.

Shop closest dupe Full comparison

More Setting Spray dupes →All On alternatives

Ranked alternatives

All dupes for On ’Til Dawn Big and Bitty Mattifying Waterproof Setting…

Every alternative is scored with our DupeScore — category overlap, savings, and match confidence. Order is computed, not sponsored.

Closest dupe

Dupe Score 86

L.A

. COLORS Matte Setting Spray (carded), Clear CBSS704…

$2.99·Save 90%·Strong dupe

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 83

Rimmel

Stay Matte Primer and Stay Matte Setting Spray

$4.98·Save 83%·Strong dupe

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 83

L.A

. Girl Pro Perfect Long-Wear Setting Spray GFS200

$4.98·Save 83%·Strong dupe

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 83

Kokie

Cosmetics Fix It Up Matte Setting Spray 2.02 Fluid Ounce

$4.98·Save 83%·Strong dupe

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 83

Beauty

Creations Watermelon Setting Spray

$6.80·Save 77%·Strong dupe

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 82

KleanColor

Pro Sealer Makeup Setting Spray - Dewy Finish (30ml)

$6.00·Save 79%·Strong dupe

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 82

Revolution

Superfix Misting Makeup Setting Spray

$6.30·Save 78%·Strong dupe

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 82

The POREfessional

Super Setter Long Lasting Makeup Setting Spray TRAVEL…

$10.43·Save 64%·Strong dupe

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 81

e.l.f. Cosmetics

Power Grip Primer and Power Grip Setting Spray Duo,…

$7.00·Save 76%·Strong dupe

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 80

Beauty

Creations Roses Setting Spray

$8.40·Save 71%·Strong dupe

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 80

Oil

Control Makeup Setting Spray

$8.99·Save 69%·Strong dupe

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 80

Make

It Last Setting Spray Jumbo Size

$10.97·Save 62%·Strong dupe

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 79

Tirtir

Waterproof Setting Spray – 24 Hour Long Lasting Fix,…

$7.98·Save 72%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 79

Beauty

Creations Tropical Setting Spray

$9.41·Save 68%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 79

Microdot

Setting Spray

$9.75·Save 66%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 79

Beauty

Creations Coconut Setting Spray

$9.99·Save 66%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 79

Beauty

Creations Cucumber Setting Spray

$9.99·Save 66%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 79

Beauty

Creations Peony Setting Spray

$9.99·Save 66%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 79

Sephora

Collection Spray and Stay Duo Set - 2 Makeup Setting…

$10.97·Save 62%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 78

Almay

Protect and Set Spray, Makeup Setting Spray, 2.7 fl oz

$9.00·Save 69%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 78

Morphe

Continuous Setting Spray for Makeup with a Radiant…

$8.99·Save 69%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 78

Billion

Dollar Beauty 2 in 1 Primer Setting Spray Hydrating…

$9.28·Save 68%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 78

Beauty

Creations Hydrating Peach Setting Spray for All Skin…

$9.41·Save 68%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 76

Ellen

Tracy Professional Coverage Setting Spray Day and…

$10.98·Save 62%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 75

Mehron Makeup Barrier Spray

2 Fl oz, Professional Makeup Setting Spray

$11.95·Save 59%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 75

Mehron Makeup Barrier Spray

9 Fl oz, Makeup Setting Spray Refill

$11.95·Save 59%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 74

2 Pc

Set Dragon Fruit and Roses Make up Setting Spray

$12.90·Save 56%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 73

M.A.C

Cosmetics Fix + Stay Over Long-Lasting Setting Spray…

$13.58·Save 53%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 72

Mist

and Fix 24 Hour Hydrating Setting Spray by Make Up For…

$13.99·Save 52%·Solid match

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 64

Tirtir

Setting Spray Duo Bundle – Mask Fit Make Up Fixer +…

$14.99·Save 48%·Worth a look

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 63

Well

People Dew Your Makeup Mist 3-in-1 Setting Spray

$14.70·Save 49%·Worth a look

Shop dupe vs On

Dupe Score 63

Luxe

Air Finish Setting Spray

$14.98·Save 48%·Worth a look

Shop dupe vs On

How we rank dupes

1. Category matchSame product type — setting spray vs setting spray, not random cross-sells.
2. DupeScoreSimilarity, savings %, and editorial confidence combined into one 0–100 score.
3. Side-by-side proofEach pick links to a full compare page with prices, specs, and an honest verdict.