Side-by-side comparison

StilavsMaybelline

Name: Stila Pocket Play Eyeshadow Palette, 5 Silky Shades
Brand: Stila
Price: 15.00 USD
Availability: InStock

Pocket Play Eyeshadow Palette, 5 Silky Shades·New York The City Mini Eyeshadow Palette Makeup,…

Side-by-side look at Stila Pocket Play Eyeshadow Palette, 5 Silky Shades ($15.0) and Maybelline New York The City Mini Eyeshadow Palette Makeup,… ($6.93) in the eyeshadow category.

Dupe Score 76Solid match

90% matchSave 54%

High confidenceShop the dupe All dupes for this product Stila brand hub

Luxury pick

Stila

Pocket Play Eyeshadow Palette, 5 Silky Shades

$15

Shop Stila Search Amazon

Budget dupe

Maybelline

New York The City Mini Eyeshadow Palette Makeup,…

$6.93

$1.67 / ml

Shop the dupe on Amazon Search Amazon

Spec	Stila	Maybelline
Category	Eyeshadow	Eyeshadow
Finish	Varies	Varies
Coverage	Varies	Varies
Volume	N/A	4.14 ml (0.1 fl oz)
Unit Price	$15	$1.67 / ml
Skin Type	All	All
Tags	Luxury	Budget

Our verdict

For a fair comparison, weigh formula claims, shade/finish, and wear time — not just price. Maybelline New York The City Mini Eyeshadow Palette Makeup,… undercuts Stila Pocket Play Eyeshadow Palette, 5 Silky Shades by about 53%, but the luxury option may still win on texture, longevity, or shade match depending on your priorities.

Shop the dupe All Stila dupes

Price drop alert